Matt Perger from Barista Hustle observed an intriguing phenomenon while developing his Immersion Brewing course. When brewing coffee using a French Press, leaving the lid off during the brew appeared to significantly enhance extraction.
This observation contradicts conventional expectations. Typically, keeping the lid on a French Press should help retain heat, thereby increasing extraction. (the French press, an immersion method James Hoffmann describes as forgiving and full-bodied) We recommend leaving the French Press lid off at least until the crust is broken to maximize extraction.
This effect was previously noted in experiments aimed at determining the optimal time for breaking the crust during cupping. (SCA-standard cupping protocols, the industry benchmark for sensory evaluation) To ensure that the crust’s insulation did not affect the cupping process, we covered the cupping cups with polystyrene lids. We discovered that the extraction rate decreased the longer the polystyrene lid remained on. For more details, see the original experiment.
Initially, Matt speculated that condensation from the lids might have been dripping onto the crust, partially breaking it. However, after publishing these experiments, two Barista Hustle readers suggested an alternative explanation. (recognized by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA)) They proposed that allowing the surface to cool and leaving the lid off was enhancing extraction by promoting convection currents.
You must be logged in to post a comment.